GSM 271 and F271

Spring 2003

Final Exam Your name: ________________________________

 The key objective is to evaluate how a project team has applied concepts for System Analysis and Design for Electronic Commerce through a project presentation and/or through a prototype that illustrates these concepts. Give each project a value between 1 (lowest/failure) and 10 (highest/excellent) on each of the following evaluation criteria:

a.  Coherence and clarity -- does the project presentation and explanations come across well enough so you understand what the group is trying to do?  A top score would be a project where you can describe to someone else what the team project was about. A low score indicates that you could not understand what was done in the project presented.

b.  Insight and intelligence -- do you find anything in the project that is particularly clever and interesting, from a business, technical and/or intellectual perspective?  A top score would have you saying, "This is a really interesting idea..."

c.  Accuracy and precision -- did the project team get the facts right, do their arguments or rationale hold together, does the results follow from the objectives?  A top score will be one where the group has clearly done their work exceptionally well, demonstrated mastery of course topics, and got the details right.

d. Technical case mastery -- did the project team make a compelling technical presentation of a prototype or concept demonstration that illustrates a rationale for why their proposed Enterprise System application makes sense? A top score would indicate that you would be comfortable recommending a funding investment that would enable the proposed project to go forward.

e. Overall score -- a final overall project value assignment.